I love writers. I really, honestly do.

But there’s a small minority – like in most professions, no doubt – who seem to think the world owes them a break.

It’s time to get real. Why do I say this? Because the same-old, same-old arguments have erupted online recently in a variety of places (bear in mind these are my words):

1. Inexperienced script editors are no use to anyone; only experienced script editors are. So how do script editors get the experience? Granted, a less experienced script editor should reflect that lesser experience in their prices. But they needn’t apologise for just starting out. Everyone has to start somewhere.

2. I’ve never heard of anyone getting a break because of using a paid-for script reader. Really? Lots of my Bang2writers place in contests, initiatives and so on – and I like to think my feedback has in part helped them do that. But even if it’s made no difference whatsoever, I always make a point of trying to facilitate relationships wherever I can. I’ve introduced writers to filmmakers on short scripts in particular, but also to agents and producers. At the moment, I’m running Pitch Me, check it out [NOW CLOSED]. But it’s ALSO worth remembering, any person who introduces a writer to someone else cannot ensure how that relationship pans out. 9/10 it will come to nothing, regardless of how great that writer or their script is. It’s not possible for the introducer to ensure all the ducks line up in a row and it’s unreasonable of any writer to expect them to. End of the day, a referral is a referral; the outcome depends not only on the quality of the writing, but the person reading it and what they need/want at that time.

3. I’d only use a script reader/editor if she were an agent’s assistant because then you’d actually have a chance of something happening. Yep; making friends with agents’ assistants is a cunning move, I’ve said it myself before. But knowing the people who know the agents’ assistants is also a good idea – oooh like me! See above. But actually, knowing ANYONE is helpful. Make contacts wherever possible; rule no one out. Who knows where they’ll be in 5 years’ time?

4. I’m sick of people like script editors trying to get my money. Seriously? You need never pay for ANYTHING. See below.

And perhaps my fave:

5. I would never pay for script reports because I met this *one* guy who was churning out the same critiques without reading writers’ scripts. Yes, there are hack readers. But guess what: there are hack writers too. Let’s not pretend that writers are white-than-white and everyone else is lurking in the sidelines, ready to grab your dosh. So, rather than tar *all* readers with the same brush, check out the readers with good “word of mouth” (or “type of script”, if the internet??). It’s easily done and should go some way to allaying any fears you have about the quality of the feedback you will receive.

None of the above are “aimed” at anyone in particular by the way, cos none are anything new. I’ve seen these arguments, time and time and time again. It seems this hoo-ha erupts at least once a year: if it’s not script readers, it’s books and “Gurus”; if it’s not books and “Gurus”, it’s events, courses or workshops; if it’s not those, then it’s competitions or Screenwriting MAs – and sometimes it’s the whole damn lot, parcelled up and condemned as the “cottage industry” that surrounds scriptwriting. That’s why I wrote this post, last year.

Fact is, writers get access to huuuuuuuuuge amounts of content, information/tips, podcasts, writing software, networking sites, peer review sites, contests, opportunities, courses, even professionals’ expertise – you name it. A writer can start writing and networking with just a laptop & an internet connection. That’s it. That’s all writers need to pay for. Writers need never buy ANYTHING. Not one thing.

But there is one thing you can’t get for free  – and that’s people’s time. Whilst most writers and people who work in the so-called “cottage industry” that surrounds scriptwriting are happy to give *some* information away for free, they do need paying for their time. So most create a balancing act where they will do *some* things free, in order to get paid work … To pay for stuff, like rent, mortgages, childcare, food – you know, normal stuff.

So I will write on this blog and give lots of writing information in the hope writers hire me to read their scripts so I can pay my bills. But no one *has* to: it’s the individual writer’s choice. Of course, some writers reckon paying for feedback is a mug’s game – and good luck to them, there are free peer review sites out there; they can go find them.

But if you feel your script could benefit from my advice, then by all means hire me. I’m booking for December and January, so I’d recommend emailing first … Because I’m in demand. There are writers out there who know a script reader’s worth – and actually, there are writers who don’t even hire script readers who know that, too. Like I said, it’s a small minority who think people involved in the fringes of scriptwriting are a bunch of money-grabbing charlatans.

As Adrian Mead always says: Keep on doing what you’re doing … And keep on getting what you’re getting. It can be positive; it can be negative. So let’s make it positive.


Post to wall at Bang2writers for peer review requests

Film Shorts Club – list your name here if you are looking for scripts/have short scripts available

Pitch Me – got one of these? Then send me your logline


For B2W offers and free stuff first, join my EMAIL LIST

7 Responses to 5 Reasons Script Readers & Editors Are Money-Grabbing Scam Merchants

  1. James Mockridge says:

    I’ve paid a script-reader for feedback; because I’m an adult and I can make my own choices.

    I accept your point of “hack readers” but you have the ‘good’ and the ‘bad’ within all walks of industry. It happens!

    Research the script-reader – Check out their feedback. See if anyone you trust has used their service before, or test the water with a short screenplay. There’s plenty of script-reading services to choose from. Including the author of this blog post (Warning – despite her fondness of chocolate, Lucy insists on *actual* cash for writing services. And not cookies. I know: I’ve tried)

    Oh, and good post.

  2. Lucy V Hay says:

    Amen to that – and thanks James. End of the day no one is forced to do anything and there’s a wealth of FREE writing advice and resources out there. Think it’s far time for those who rally against the “cottage industry” to move on.

  3. I agree…for the most part. IF you are paying a service hoping to get ‘discovered’ then you are flushing money down the toilet. But if you are struggling with structure or have a weak character or things are not real enough I have found that hiring a qualified reader can be beneficial. I have employed college professors to go over my scripts. Writing is one of the rare fields that university professors are a brilliant resource if for no other reason than they have read and discussed tons of stories and are generally good communicators. So with all of that information bumping around in their brains and the ability to discuss how it relates to your work, they tend to be good people. Particularly when they have NEVER done it professionally.

  4. Lucy V Hay says:

    Yep – any script reading service should focus principally on that, the actual reading … NOT “connecting” writers to anyone. This is not B2W’s primary remit and I’d never charge writers to introduce them to anyone, which personally I think is wrong. I read scripts, first and foremost. If I think of a particular script or writer when someone asks me whose work I like, I will say so, whether I’ve read it via B2W, London Screenwriters Festival or somewhere else.

  5. Kim says:

    Could not agree more. As a script editor and script developer that has worked both freelance and with companies, I can say that the attitude to the job role can be a joke at points.

    I am also a writer and I can fully appreciate that I cannot edit my own work. Why? Because it is difficult to set your vision aside from what will actually make the vision work.

  6. […] to accumulate … You can’t/won’t? Then fine: don’t. You don’t have to. Writers need never pay a penny for the writing information & opportunities that are out there. Not one single […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>